It's holiday season again. Silver and gold decorations abound on lamp posts, storefronts, and front doors. Some of you may have teeth to match - silver and gold fillings that most likely have been there longer than the old fruitcake in the back of the cupboard. Metal dental materials have gotten a bad rap over the last decade, especially as some of the more esthetic materials like porcelain and composite have improved. I have quite a few requests for completely metal-free dentistry. Some of that reputation is rightly deserved, but certain metals can actually be a good choice in specific situations. Let me explain why, in our office, we have chosen to use some metals, and avoid others, and when they are best suited for your mouth.
If you're over the age of 20 and you have a history of dental work, there's a good chance one or more of your fillings is silver amalgam. First introduced in the 1800's, silver amalgam is still used today as a low-cost alternative to the more aesthetic, tooth-colored composite resin. Amalgam is an alloy of mercury (~50%), silver (~30%), tin, copper, and zinc. There has been a lot of media attention on the presence of mercury in silver fillings. Some countries have outlawed them for use in pregnant women or small children. The American Dental Association has long supported their use and the FDA has continued to agree. Regardless of the controversy, silver amalgam has one very significant drawback that has prevented us from using it in our office for over 10 years: it breaks teeth. Witness exhibit A:

This upper molar seemingly had nothing wrong with it. That silver filling had been in the patient's mouth for 20+ years and never gave the patient any problems. Then one day, while eating something innocuous, a huge piece of the tooth fractured right off. Notice the filling is still in place, but the tooth around it is gone. This is very typical of what happens to teeth with silver amalgam fillings. Why? Silver amalgam is not bonded to the tooth, like composite resin. It is simply wedged into place. After placement, the metal expands and puts undue forces on the enamel. Microfractures start to form around the filling that continue to grow, much like a star in your car windshield, and can eventually split the tooth. If you're lucky, the fracture will just occur through the dentin, as it did here. Sometimes it can fracture into the nerve of the tooth, necessitating a root canal. And in really unfortunate cases it can actually split the tooth right in half, down the root, and require extraction. Major bummer from something as small as a silver filling. For this reason, we encourage our patients to consider removing the silver BEFORE the tooth breaks and placing a bonded filling that will hold the tooth together, preserve more of the natural tooth structure, and look a whole lot better. Witness exhibit B:
Now, what about gold? Gold is a different story. Gold does not wedge teeth apart - to get a bit scientific, it has a very similar coefficient of expansion as natural tooth structure. Gold also wears at a very similar rate as enamel, which means it is soft on the opposing teeth. For this reason, gold is a fantastic option for people who grind or clench their teeth. You can't break it, it won't break your other teeth, and, barring recurrent decay, it will probably last for well over 10 years. True, it is not the most aesthetic option, but when it comes to function and longevity it really is the gold standard, no pun intended.
So this holiday season, when it comes to your mouth, think about ditching the silver and keeping the gold.